How to Tell Whether a Learning Community Is Alive: Sense of Community, Shared Practice and Response Rates
Look at whether things go back and forth between members, not at sign-ups or message volume: does a check-in get a response within 72 hours, do people who got a response come back within 7 days, is more than one core member responding to newcomers, and is the group building up practice others can reuse. Most new communities die within three months (57% of 472,231 new Facebook groups stopped posting), and groups with a single admin whose founder added every member die sooner.