How to Classify Code Review Comments? From Conventional Comments to AI Review Tool Taxonomies
Three main classification systems dominate: Conventional Comments (label-based), Google's severity prefixes (Nit/Optional/FYI), and SonarQube's four quadrants (Bug/Vulnerability/Code Smell/Hotspot). AI review tools have each developed their own taxonomies, but the core dimensions consistently converge on four areas: correctness, security, performance, and maintainability.