Skip to content

Climbing Cat Ba Island: Choosing Between Fisher, Hidden and Butterfly | Vietnam Climbing Crags

Oct 21, 20261 min
TL;DRCat Ba Island's 178 routes split into five sectors: Butterfly Valley is the biggest but has the oldest bolts, Fisher Valley was taken over by Cat Ba Climbing and has been rebolted and improved from the 2024 typhoon all the way through 2026, and Hidden Valley has overhanging roof routes and a small bouldering cave; permits cost 30,000 VND for Fisher and 50,000 VND for Hidden, Ben Beo has been closed by a government announcement, and a helmet is mandatory everywhere on the island.

Look up & save

Loading dictionary…

🌏 中文版

Cat Ba Island is the closest thing Vietnam has to an island holiday for climbing: jungle on top of the limestone cliffs, beaches and jetties down below. But everything here works differently from other crags — climbing on the island is "tolerated rather than permitted": you buy a permit, you pay the landowner, bolt condition changes from sector to sector, and even the question of whether you are allowed to climb has been taken up by the government before.

This guide helps you plan two days on the island: go with the old crag with the old bolts, Butterfly Valley, or put the time into Fisher and Hidden, the two newer sectors maintained by local operators.

What kind of crag

Cat Ba Island is 2.5 to 3.5 hours southeast of Hanoi by road (including the ferry), and it is the southern gateway to Ha Long Bay and Lan Ha Bay. theCrag's area description calls it "mainly limestone sport climbing, 178 routes," with grades from 3a all the way to 9a.

  • Five sectors: Butterfly Valley / Liên Minh (71 routes), Squanch Wall / Fisher Valley (44 routes), Hidden Valley / The Farm (38 routes), The Cave / Buddha Cave (17 routes), Ben Beo Harbour (8 routes, closed).
  • Style: roofs, slabs, tufa and vertical walls all at once. The Hidden Valley description reads: "From good-gripping routes to slab routes to overhanging roof climbing, the range of styles is wide. A good place to learn lead climbing or multi-pitch". There is also a small bouldering cave.
  • Rock and bolts: everything on the island is limestone, but the bolts range from old glue-ins from 2007 to new stainless steel placed in 2026, so each sector has to be judged on its own.
  • Who it suits: people who want to fit two or three days of climbing into an island trip. Flying in for climbing alone is not worth it, but it slots neatly in between Hanoi and Lan Ha Bay.

The most important sentence here repeats in the ethics field of every sector page: "Considering that rockfall can happen outdoors at any time, please understand that a helmet is necessary for climbing anywhere on this island." The same paragraph adds: "The Vietnamese government is looking for a reason to close climbing in this area; do not be the reason we lose access to this beautiful area."

When to go

theCrag is direct about the season on Cat Ba: "The winter months are ideal for sport climbing, with cool temperatures (10 to 20 °C) and low rainfall (5 to 25 mm per month)." The downside of winter is the tide, and that is a deep-water bouldering problem, not a problem for the crags on the island.

Hanoi's climate table works as an inland reference (same monsoon system; Cat Ba is an island, so the temperature range is smaller than Hanoi's):

MonthAverage high / lowRainfallRain daysSunshine hoursPlan
December21.3 / 13.8 °C19.5 mm5.1 days124 hoursDriest and sunniest, and Butterfly Valley is quiet
January20.2 / 14.1 °C19.8 mm10.3 days74 hoursJust as little rain, but many more rainy days
February21.7 / 16.4 °C20.2 mm12.4 days45 hoursSunshine drops noticeably
March25.9 / 20.5 °C35.8 mm15.9 days47 hoursRainy season starts

The rainy season directly changes whether you can walk into the crag. The Butterfly Valley page says: "The valley floods in the rainy season, so some routes cannot be reached, and the alternative approach is to go around the upper rock overhang." The Cave "stays dry apart from the walls sweating when humidity hits 100%", but the approach is a 5-minute steep climb, and after rain they "recommend wearing solid shoes".

Sorting out sun is simpler here than in the main valleys, because there are fewer walls. Fisher Valley is tagged "dry in the rain, sunny in the morning, sheltered", the most comfortable face on the island; Hidden Valley is tagged "almost fully shaded, sheltered, dry in light rain"; Butterfly Valley is tagged "dry in the rain, sunny in the morning, wet in the rain" — two walls in one sector with different notes.

Getting there

Public transport

  • Hanoi ⇄ Cat Ba Island bus: 300,000 VND, booked through Cat Ba Climbing, which handles the ferry along with it. The other option is the Ninh Bình ⇄ Cat Ba Island bus, also 300,000 VND, with pickup from the center of Cat Ba town or from hotels on the main road.
  • Island bus: to reach The Cave, take route 14 from Cát Hài to the cable car crossing stop, every 30 minutes, 13,000 VND (2026 price), and the drop-off point is right by Ha Sen Road.
  • The ferry and the bus are the same ticket. Leave buffer in the plan: the official time from Hanoi, ferry included, is 2.5 to 3.5 hours.

Driving

  • Private car from Hanoi or Noi Bai airport ⇄ Cat Ba Island: 2,000,000 VND, door-to-door, ferry included, 2.5 to 3.5 hours.
  • Haiphong or Cat Ba airport ⇄ Cat Ba Island has three options: a direct drive plus ferry (1,300,000 VND including the ferry ticket), a split trip (taxi plus ferry plus taxi, 1,000,000 VND excluding the ferry ticket), or a speedboat plus car (price and schedule have to be asked about separately). All three include pickup from your hotel in Cat Ba town.
  • On the island you move by motorbike or e-bike. Cat Ba Climbing rents bikes and e-bikes (150,000 VND), and theCrag's description for independent climbers says "all you need is a motorbike or a bicycle". Local taxis are 80,000 VND; a motorbike taxi (xe om) from town to Ben Beo takes 3 minutes for 10,000 VND.
  • Hữu Lũng ⇄ Cat Ba Island private car: 2,580,000 VND; there is no direct bus on a fixed schedule.

Parking

SectorWhere to parkCost
Fisher ValleyRide 12 km north from Cat Ba town (about 25–35 minutes) past Woodstock toward Cat Ba Eco Lodge, with the wall on your right; go around the north end of the reservoir, park at the junction behind it, open the gate on the left, walk the path down to the wall, and close the gate when you leavePermit 30,000 VND (2026)
Hidden ValleyDrive 5 minutes from town or walk 10 minutes to the car park, then about 10 minutes of steep uphill to the wallPermit 50,000 VND (2026), bought from the landowner at Pizza Hanh Bakery by the gate
Butterfly Valley10 km from Cat Ba town; for approach details on individual routes, ask Langur's AdventuresPermit from Langur's, plus 30,000 VND to the farm on the south side of the wall
The CavePark in the alley at number 44 on the north side of Ha Sen Road, pay the homeowner on the way in or out, then 5 minutes of steep uphill20,000 VND exit tip (October 2026)
Ben Beo20 minutes on foot from Cat Ba town, or a 3-minute xe om; look left from the harbour gate, at the cliff beside the brown hotelClosed

The parking and approach setup at Fisher Valley is the best of the bunch: since 2022 the approach path has been improved, toilets and showers built, and a few platforms added for resting and looking out. There is WiFi at the wall, and climbing numbers have doubled as a result.

Rules before you go

Permits differ between the four sectors and are not interchangeable. Fisher is 30,000, Hidden 50,000 VND (both 2026 prices), Butterfly needs a permit from Langur's plus 30,000 to the farm, and The Cave is 20,000 paid on the way out. Work out which sectors you are climbing before you decide how the money is carried.

Fisher Valley has the newest bolts on the island. The sector was opened by Asia Outdoors in early 2019 and is now held by Cat Ba Climbing; Typhoon Yagi wrecked the place in 2024, and repairs and improvements have run all the way to 2026, including a new bouldering area and rebuilt viewing platforms. Hidden Valley is also held and maintained by Cat Ba Climbing / Mr. Zoom, which opened new routes there in 2024.

Butterfly Valley is the oldest sector and carries the most warnings. It was developed between 2007 and 2010 by Erik Ferjentsik and Onslo Carrington, and is "the biggest crag on Cat Ba Island". The fixed-point warnings on the page include: "black rusty bolts", "the 7th bolt is loose", "hornet nest at the anchor", "no more fixed points" (listed twice), "rock still falling", "rockfall all the time", "most bolts and the top look very rusty". There is no rebolting note anywhere.

Hidden Valley's warnings: broken anchor bolts, the first hanger has been removed; rusty bolts.

Fisher Valley's warnings: one route needs "14 quickdraws plus fixed points"; loose anchor bolts; a snake behind the first anchor.

Fixed points are not there for top-roping. The ethics field in several sectors says: "Many routes here have horn anchors, permanent carabiners or quickdraws, so use this gear only for lowering and cleaning. If you want to top-rope any route, set up your own anchor system."

The Cave has a Buddha statue and owls. The area description says "there is a shrine in the cave, and protected wildlife (owls)", and the ethics field says "there is a Buddhist meditation area in the cave, please be respectful, and climb only in the designated areas".

Ben Beo has been closed by a government announcement. theCrag is blunt about it: "The government has officially and forcibly closed this crag. Please respect this closure and move on to the other beautiful crags in the area." The same page still lists 8 routes and a 25,000 VND access fee. This is a database-level notice, and the matching government announcement text was not found; in practice, treat it as closed and do not go.

Do not bribe officials. theCrag spells this one out: "Somebody has tried to bribe, and the result is a very bad precedent that will only make things more difficult in the future."

Emergency numbers: police 113, fire 114, ambulance 115; national search and rescue 020 7008 5000 (24 hours, Vietnamese only). The island has medical resources but they are limited in scope, and every Cat Ba Climbing trip includes travel insurance of up to 100,000,000 VND — when you buy your own, check item by item that it covers outdoor climbing, search and rescue, and evacuation.

Routes by level

YDS and V-grade conversions follow the Mountain Project international grade comparison chart and are approximate; "approx." marks grades the sources give without a/b/c (such as 4 or 5+). The original grade is the one that counts.

Beginner: up to 6a (YDS 5.10a and below)

Butterfly Valley and Hidden Valley are the two beginner powerhouses; Fisher Valley's short routes are the cleanest.

RouteGradeYDSLength or pitchesSectorNotes
Baby steps3approx. 5.22 mButterfly ValleytheCrag 2 stars; the easiest route on the island
Potato launcher4+approx. 5.630 mButterfly ValleytheCrag 2 stars
Earth Wind & Fire4+approx. 5.610 mThe CavetheCrag 1 star
3d Tufas 1015a5.712 mThe CavetheCrag 1 star
Where the Wild Things Were5b5.818 mThe CavetheCrag 1 star
Kiwis first steps5c5.913 mThe CavetheCrag 1 star
Chuyen Nui5a5.720 mButterfly ValleytheCrag 1 star
5 Fun5a5.722 mButterfly ValleytheCrag 1 star
Vu Duyen5c5.98 mButterfly ValleytheCrag 1 star
Bread and Butter5c5.923 mButterfly ValleytheCrag 1 star
Monkey Magic5a5.77 mHidden ValleytheCrag 2 stars; small bouldering cave
No Worries4+approx. 5.67 mHidden ValleytheCrag 1 star
No Problem4+approx. 5.67 mHidden ValleytheCrag 1 star
First Time Get It4+approx. 5.67 mHidden ValleytheCrag 1 star
Tarzan5b5.87 mHidden ValleytheCrag 1 star
Jane5c5.97 mHidden ValleytheCrag 1 star
Pick Pocket5b5.811 mHidden ValleytheCrag 2 stars
Green Lungs5c5.913 mHidden ValleytheCrag 2 stars
Duck on the Lake5a5.78 mFisher ValleytheCrag 1 star
Cosmiclea5a5.712 mFisher ValleytheCrag 1 star
Funky Town5b5.820 mFisher ValleytheCrag 2 stars
Chimney Sweep5b5.822 mFisher ValleytheCrag 2 stars
White Boy Shuffle5b5.820 mFisher ValleytheCrag 2 stars
Long Black5b5.818 mFisher ValleytheCrag 2 stars
Walmart Cookies5b5.89 mFisher ValleytheCrag 2 stars
Funk in the Trunk5c5.923 mFisher ValleytheCrag 2 stars
Face to Face5c5.912 mFisher ValleytheCrag 1 star
Flying Squirrel6a5.10a20 mFisher ValleytheCrag 2 stars
Mechanic Hands6a5.10a27 mFisher ValleytheCrag 2 stars
Dark Dihedral6a5.10a11 mHidden ValleytheCrag 1 star
Slingswing6a5.10a18 mThe CavetheCrag 2 stars

Intermediate: 6a+ to 6c+ (YDS 5.10b–5.11c)

Fisher Valley's intermediate tier is concentrated in the long routes near 6c (30 to 38 m), while Hidden Valley has short routes and slabs from 6b to 6c+.

RouteGradeYDSLength or pitchesSectorNotes
Moustache Massage Man6a+5.10b8 mButterfly ValleytheCrag 1 star
Unobbtainable HR6a+5.10b12 mButterfly ValleytheCrag 2 stars
Intrigues6a5.10a28 mButterfly Valleyno stars on theCrag
Dublin Mudslide6a5.10a25 mButterfly ValleytheCrag 1 star
The Grass Is Always Greener6b5.10c23 mButterfly ValleytheCrag 2 stars
Very Tot6b+5.10d21 mButterfly ValleytheCrag 2 stars
Fingerless Pho Man6c+5.11c20 mButterfly ValleytheCrag 2 stars
Miyagi Box Maker6c+5.11c20 mButterfly ValleytheCrag 3 stars
Bolts 'R' us6c+5.11c16 mButterfly ValleytheCrag 3 stars
Cracker Jack6c5.11a/b21 mButterfly ValleytheCrag 2 stars
Over the Moon6a+5.10b23 mThe CavetheCrag 2 stars
Breakout6b+5.10d18 mThe CavetheCrag 2 stars; can still be wet after rain
Namastay on the wall6b+5.10d17 mThe CavetheCrag 3 stars
Srew You6b5.10c20 mHidden ValleytheCrag 2 stars
Nesto's Gift6b5.10c18 mHidden ValleytheCrag 3 stars
Bozo's Big Day6b5.10c21 mHidden ValleytheCrag 2 stars
Ich Will In Dich Sein6a+5.10b18 mHidden ValleytheCrag 2 stars
House of Jugs6c5.11a/b17 mHidden ValleytheCrag 3 stars
Which Way To The Beach6c+5.11c15 mHidden ValleytheCrag 2 stars
Kenzie Town6a+5.10b20 mFisher ValleytheCrag 2 stars
Butchered Olives6a+5.10b18 mFisher ValleytheCrag 2 stars
Liv to Climb Another Day6b5.10c23 mFisher ValleytheCrag 3 stars
Careful, She Bites!6b+5.10d20 mFisher ValleytheCrag 2 stars
Spender Bender6b+5.10d24 mFisher ValleytheCrag 1 star
River of Strength6b5.10c24 mFisher ValleytheCrag 1 star
Eternal Squanch6c5.11a/b35 mFisher ValleytheCrag 3 stars
Hernadez the Hernia6c+5.11c30 mFisher ValleytheCrag 2 stars
Iron Lion6c+5.11c24 mFisher ValleytheCrag 2 stars
Convoluted Corner6c5.11a/b16 mFisher ValleytheCrag 3 stars
Ants Marching Left6c5.11a/b38 mFisher ValleytheCrag 2 stars; paired with Ants Marching Right

Advanced: 7a to 7c+ (YDS 5.11d–5.13a)

Butterfly Valley has the most routes in the 7s (more than 20), Fisher Valley is concentrated from 7a to 7c+, and Hidden Valley's own description singles out overhanging roof climbs — Shampoo Effect is the sector's signature route.

RouteGradeYDSLength or pitchesSectorNotes
My Way7a+5.12a18 mButterfly ValleytheCrag 2 stars
Team Ling Ling7a+5.12a28 mButterfly ValleytheCrag 3 stars, 14 bolts
Buffalo Love7a+5.12a26 mButterfly ValleytheCrag 3 stars, 15 bolts
Pappi's Paradise7a5.11d28 mButterfly ValleytheCrag 2 stars, 14 bolts
Obama 1017a5.11d20 mButterfly ValleytheCrag 2 stars, 12 bolts
Up Syndrome7a5.11d20 mButterfly ValleytheCrag 2 stars, 13 bolts
Windchime of the Ants7a5.11d28 mButterfly ValleytheCrag 2 stars, 13 bolts
Thanks For The Memories7b5.12b31 mButterfly ValleytheCrag 3 stars, 15 bolts
Pole Dancer7b5.12b22 mButterfly ValleytheCrag 3 stars, 9 bolts
Chia Tay7b5.12b20 mButterfly ValleytheCrag 1 star, 12 bolts
Prayer Of The Mantis7b5.12b20 mButterfly ValleytheCrag 3 stars, 11 bolts
Freakonomics7b5.12b27 mButterfly ValleytheCrag 3 stars, 13 bolts
Hippie Banana Tree Killer7b+5.12c25 mButterfly ValleytheCrag 3 stars, 13 bolts
Passive Aggressive7b+5.12c21 mButterfly ValleytheCrag 1 star, 11 bolts
Year of the Tiger7c5.12d26 mButterfly ValleytheCrag 2 stars, 12 bolts
Dream Weaver7c+5.13a22 mButterfly ValleytheCrag 3 stars, 13 bolts
Horseless Samurai7c+5.13a27 mButterfly ValleytheCrag 3 stars, 15 bolts
Monarch7c+5.13a25 mButterfly ValleytheCrag 3 stars, 13 bolts
Fistful of Stalactite7a+5.12a17 mThe CavetheCrag 3 stars
Chó cái for life7a5.11d17 mThe CavetheCrag 3 stars
Mr Zoom7c/c+5.12d10 mThe CavetheCrag 3 stars; the shortest and hardest route in the cave
Test Pilot7a5.11d22 mHidden ValleytheCrag 2 stars, 12 bolts
Monocle Man7a+5.12a16 mHidden ValleytheCrag 3 stars, 11 bolts
Shampoo Effect7b+5.12c17 mHidden ValleytheCrag 3 stars; roof route
Power & Good Vibes7b5.12b13 mHidden ValleytheCrag 2 stars
Next Time Get It7b5.12b26 mHidden ValleytheCrag 2 stars, 14 bolts
Bird Snake7a5.11d30 mFisher ValleytheCrag 1 star, 12 bolts
Root Vine7a5.11d38 mFisher ValleytheCrag 3 stars, 14 bolts
Tesco ya Slut7a5.11d40 mFisher ValleytheCrag 2 stars, 15 bolts
Formic Acid7a+5.12a24 mFisher ValleytheCrag 3 stars, 10 bolts; roof section
Kangaroo Jack7a+5.12a18 mFisher ValleytheCrag 2 stars
Indispensable Knowledge7b5.12b28 mFisher ValleytheCrag 2 stars, 8 bolts
Tampon Finger Joe7c5.12d27 mFisher ValleytheCrag 3 stars, 9 bolts
Lipstick on a Pear7c+5.13a30 mFisher ValleytheCrag 3 stars, 12 bolts

Expert: 8a and up (YDS 5.13b and up)

Butterfly Valley has the hardest routes on the island, but it also has the oldest bolt condition — read the two together.

RouteGradeYDSLength or pitchesSectorNotes
My Way Or The Railway8a5.13b28 mButterfly ValleytheCrag 3 stars, 13 bolts
Butterfly Effect8a5.13b12 mButterfly ValleytheCrag 3 stars, 10 bolts
Enter The Dragon8a+5.13c35 mButterfly ValleytheCrag 3 stars, 14 bolts
Roman's Karmic Curse8a+5.13c17 mButterfly Valleyno stars on theCrag, 10 bolts
Guerrero Argentino8c+/9a5.14c25 mButterfly Valleyno stars on theCrag, 14 bolts; hardest on the island
El Loco Bee8a+/b5.13c8 mThe CavetheCrag 1 star, 4 bolts; short burst route in the cave

Bouldering

The small bouldering cave in Hidden Valley has five problems; theCrag lists V grades directly, with no Font grades to convert.

RouteV gradeSectorNotes
Fat SantaV1Hidden Valley4 m
Total Eclipse Of The HeartV3Hidden Valley4 m
Under The BridgeV6Hidden Valley4 m
Scotch MistV6Hidden Valley4 m
Around The WorldV7Hidden Valley4 m, theCrag 3 stars

Trad

RouteOriginal gradeYDSLength or pitchesWallNotes
Firefly5.115.11—Butterfly ValleytheCrag 1 star; the original grade is already YDS, so it is not converted again
Approach to Trad5b5.88 mButterfly ValleytheCrag 2 stars; short sport route linking to the trad section

Where to look things up

  • theCrag: Cat Ba Island: the index of 178 routes, the access rules for the island, the current state of gear rental, and history.
  • theCrag: Fisher Valley, Hidden Valley, Butterfly Valley, The Cave, Ben Beo Harbour: approaches, permit prices, fixed-point warnings and development history for each sector.
  • Cat Ba Climbing: trip and transfer prices, rental gear in Cat Ba, and how each area has been run since 2016. Their office is at 120 Nui Ngoc Street in Cat Ba town, WhatsApp +84 347645000.
  • Langur's Adventures: where to get the Butterfly Valley permit, and half-day trips in sport climbing and deep water soloing (DWS), 1,300,000 VND each.
  • Guidebook: Grades and route counts here come mainly from online databases; the guidebook is the authority.
    • 《Vietnam Climbing》, Luca De Giorgi and Gavi Piper, second edition 2023, 230 pages, ISBN 9781727545128, in English. Sport climbing and deep-water bouldering in Ha Long Bay and Cat Ba Island are the core of the book, and it comes with a Vertical-Life app redemption code.
    • A copy of 《Vietnam Climbing》 is also sold locally on Cat Ba, 600,000 VND in the Cat Ba Climbing shop; the product description gives it as the 2018 edition covering Ha Long Bay / Lan Ha Bay / Cat Ba Island, while theCrag's Lan Ha Bay page describes a guidebook for the same area published in 2016, 140 pages. The two descriptions do not agree on the edition, so go by the physical copy before you buy.

References